Dan's Metablog
Writing about blogging, identity, and narrative


Blog as nominalization   Thursday, April 27   11:05 PM

My advisor drew an exclamation point next to my first and only use of the verb-form of "blog" in my paper, which brought to mind an important if little-noted fact:

The noun "blog" is a nominalization.

If we believe Peter Merholz's account of the coinage of "blog," it came from his splitting "weblog" into "we blog." Maybe he (or others) have a different analysis, but it seems to me like "we" is the subject and "blog" is verb.

The noun form follows naturally, but it still had to follow. Can we still say "blog" is a short form of "weblog"? Looks more like the result of a visual pun. Or something; I'm no etymologist.

I'd bring this up with Language Log if I hadn't already pestered them last week about "spaz."

Comments (5)



Hey Dan, how ya doin!

Certainly it's of interest to track down the actual historical path of a derivation. (Though there's no saying it's unique.)

But along with that let's not denigrate the synchronic status a word has in the (mental) lexicons of contemporary speakers. Here also there is a need for genuine scholarly investigation as distinct from mere (or even informed) speculation. Unfortunately, the latter is all I can offer now! :)

But in that spirit: Of course the nouns were both ('weblog' and 'blog') in place before the verb 'blog' could come along. So there's little ground for the label of nominalization.

I'm not sure of the context, but ... Remember the role of the label 'that's a nominalization' in pedagogic and editorial stylistics. Sometimes it clarifies what's wrong with a really messy construction. But at other times, having been elevated to something like a rule, it becomes cover for an otherwise-unexplained objection. Also, although indeed any V -> N (or A -> N) derivation might technically qualify a nominalization (and indeed might contribute to stylistic unpleasantness), typically the label is invoked when the derivation is done by affixing, and 'blog' (if assumed to be a V -> N derivation, which remains unlikely) might claim exemption from the stylistic "rule" against nominalizations on this ground.

Best regards,

Mitch




I said:

[quote]
Remember the role of the label 'that's a nominalization' in pedagogic and editorial stylistics
[/quote]

I meant to say 'rhetoric' in there. A piece of my own rhetorical stance I guess. Did I ever mmention at one point I was a Lector in the Little Red Schoolhouse, and then a writing tutor attached to a Common Core course? Nominalization was our enemy, and Joe Williams made a great case against it. But here I'm emphasizing that it was indeed a matter of making a case.

== Mitch

posted by Anonymous mitch marks at 2:12 AM, September 20, 2006  



To blog is more of a verbalization (or whatever the term is) from the noun blog (which is weblog shortened).

posted by Anonymous TCO at 9:48 AM, April 10, 2009  



discount Christian Louboutin
cheap Christian Louboutin Pumps
Tiffany Silver Jewelry
cheap Jimmy Choo shoes
cheap Jimmy Choo
nike dunk

posted by Anonymous cheap Jimmy Choo shoes at 2:05 AM, December 04, 2009  



discount Christian Louboutin
cheap Christian Louboutin Pumps
Tiffany Silver Jewelry
cheap Jimmy Choo shoes
cheap Jimmy Choo
nike dunk

posted by Anonymous cheap Jimmy Choo shoes at 2:07 AM, December 04, 2009  


Leave a Comment


Alles Wird Gut

Navigate

Discourse History
Top 20 Citations
All Citations
Master's Thesis

Dan's Metablog

Links

BlogBib
Bloggers Blog
BROG Project
Google Scholar
Into the Blogosphere
JCMC
MLA styleguide

Dan's Webpage

Recent posts

Open mouth, insert foot?
First draft
Our bold blog definition
If Blood says she loves you...
Post-meeting aside
The first 15 pages
Prelude to progress?
Snag.
Another sidenote: How blogs end
Prelude to a very long post

Del.icio.us
My del.ic.ious site feed

delicious icon  my del.icio.us

Archives

October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
July 2006
December 2006


Website XML feed

Creative Commons License

Blogger button