Dan's Webpage
Because everyone loves a farce



Wednesday, June 23   12:24 PM

Good argument there. No argument here.

Though the guys at Spiked are used to dealing with the half-hearted socialism of Blair's government, I think that Brandon Robshaw's proposal could fly even in our (ostensibly) more liberty-minded country. He makes an excellent point.

What's wrong with a national DNA register?

My knee-jerk reaction is to worry about the immigrants. Would people not born in Britain be forced to submit their DNA for police use? If so, then one of the objections that Robshaw skirts through use of the already mandatory heel test for infants would actually stand.

There's an interesting albeit unlikely doomsday scenario on the flip side of this coin. If non-natives were exempted, the relative ease with which they could avoid police detection (theirs being, eventually, the only DNA not on file) could precipitate the development of a highly-sophisticated criminal class.

All non-natives would be suspected of belonging to that class, and obvious foreigners would be both feared and discriminated against. Well-connected plutocrats could hire the real criminals as assassins or thieves.

(Holy etymology! Neal Stephenson was right about "assassins" — it really does come from the Arabic word for "hashish user.")

Anyways, I think it's a solid idea, even if some of its more far-fetched ramifications make me want to go write some sci-fi.

Leave a Comment


Alles Wird Gut

Navigate

Blogosphere blog
Drink blog
Language blog

Back to Main

Taste

My del.ic.ious site feed

View

My flickr site feed

Review

And here begins the status quo
"Not a butterfly!" cried Eckels.
A second night out in Brainerd
Like the AP news, except it's useless
Angst And Autos
Leavetakings
Last Wednesday
And Just Like The Movies
Two Cathedrals
Stupid Dan

Visit

Annie
Ben
Laura
Dooce

Achewood
Basic Instructions
Beartato
Cat and Girl
Dinosaur Comics
Hark! A Vagrant
Penny Arcade
Overcompensating
Pictures for Sad Children
White Ninja Comics
Wonderella

Bartleby
Julian Sanchez
Language Log
Megan McArdle
MnBeer
Netvibes
Who is IOZ?


Website XML feed

Creative Commons License

Blogger button